University of Florida

EVALUATING SEARCH ENGINES FOR AND WITH K-12 STUDENTS

INTRODUCTION
Scope of this Project
Standards Addressed

COMPARING SEARCH ENGINES
Introduction
Evaluation Criteria
Comparison Chart

SEARCH ENGINES FEATURED
AOL@SCHOOL
Ask Jeeves Kids
Awesome Library
CyberSleuth Kids
KidsClick
Librarians' Internet Index
OneKey (Google Safe Search)
Open Directory Project (Kids and Teens)
Yahooligans!

STUDENT ACTIVITIES
Elementary Lesson Plan
Middle/High School Lesson
Interactive Search Tool Finder

FEEDBACK
Education Search Features
Your Favorite Search Engine

ABOUT ME
Ginger Lindberg


CyberSmart! Curriculum
CHOOSING A SEARCH SITE
Download Student Activity Sheet(s) for printout in PDF Format

Overview
Through online observations, students record and compare the features of four children's search sites. They then construct a lift-the-flap poster that will guide them in selecting appropriate search sites.

Objectives
  Identify some children's search sites
  Compare and contrast features of specific search sites
  Explain why it is best to utilize two or more sites when searching for information

ISTE® National Technology Standards
  Performance Indicator # 9

Site Preview
  Preview the children's search sites selected for this lesson.

Online Resources
  Visit sites providing background information on Search Engines and Directories.

Materials
  Activity sheets (3)
  Scissors; paste
  Online computer access
  Printer access
 

Introduce (offline)
  Tell students that they will compare some children's search sites. Explain that each search site has different features and that they may like some more than others.

Teach 1 (online)
  Distribute Activity Sheet 1.
  Take students to www.becybersmart.org and click on the triangle. Find the title of this lesson, and open its links.
  Assign each student or group of students to one of the four children's search sites to visit.
  Have students answer the questions by checking the boxes for each question.

Teach 2 (offline/online)
  Have students report their recorded observations to the rest of the class. If there are discrepancies about the features of a site, revisit the site to resolve them.
  Post the printouts of the search results for "kites." Have students compare the results, noticing that each search engine produced a different list of Web pages.
  Explain that by using more than one search engine, students will have a greater number of sites to visit.
  Have students discuss their answers to "What do you like best about this site?" encouraging the class to identify features that distinguish the sites.

Teach 3 (offline)
  Distribute Activity Sheets 2 and 3.
  Have students cut the six flaps on the dotted lines and fold the solid lines on Activity Sheet 2. Then have them align and paste Activity Sheet 2 over Activity Sheet 3 so that when the flaps are lifted, the answers are displayed.

Close (offline)
  Ask: What are the names of some children's search sites? (i.e. Ask Jeeves for Kids®, KidsClick!®, Yahooligans!®)
  Ask: In what ways do these search sites differ? (the ways you can search, how they display results, and the other features/activities they offer)
  Ask: Why is it a good idea to use more than one search site when looking for information? (Because different sites will give different results.)
  Ask: How will using the poster you made help you search? (It can help you pick the best search site for your needs.)
 

Extend (offline)
The following activity can be added for students who completed this lesson in a previous grade.
  Have students select their own search topic, and use the lift-the-flap poster to choose the best search sites.

 

Source: The CyberSmart Education Company, "Choosing a Search Site." [Online] 2006. <http://www.cybersmartcurriculum.org/lesson_plans/45_14.asp>.