Comparative Constitutional History, Spring 2007
Thursday 3-5 PM
Holland Hall 350
Professor: Elizabeth Dale
Office hours: Thursday 10-11AM & 1:30-2:15 at law school (Room 240E, library)
By appointment at Keene Flint, main campus
Email: edale1@history.ufl.edu
Required books (at law school bookstore):
Jacobsohn, Apple of Gold (1993)
Klug, Constituting Democracy (2000)
Brown, Constitutions in a Nonconstitutional World (2001)
Kuhn, Origins of the
Moore and Robinson, Partners for Democracy (2004)
Fitzsimmons,
Remaking of
Brzezinski,
Struggle for Constitutionalism in
Berg and Geyer, Two Cultures of Rights (2006)
Anastapolo,
Online resources:
http://edale1.typepad.com/conhist/ (online archive of news and other resources about comparative constitutionalism)
http://www.constitution.org/cons/natlcons.htm (collection of constitutions, mostly modern)
http://www.oefre.unibe.ch/law/icl/info.html (another collection of modern constitutions, in English translation)
http://www.yale.edu/lawweb/avalon/ (collection of mostly US constitutional and legal documents)
http://pdba.georgetown.edu/Comp/note.html
(collection of constitutions in the
Assignments:
Class presentation: 25% of grade
Book review: 25% of grade
15 page paper: 50% of grade
The class presentation involves being the “class expert” on one of the documents assigned for a given week. Two students may be experts (on different documents) in the same week.
The book review is a 5-7 page (double spaced) analysis of one of the books on the book review list. You may substitute a book of your own choosing, but you must get my permission to do so and you must have that approval by Feb. 22.
The 15 page paper (double spaced) will
be a historical look at one country (or region) we studied in class. Your paper
can focus on a particular constitutional problem (how and why does the South
African constitution recognize social rights?), offer a comparison between two
or more constitutions (how has citizenship changed in Mexico’s constitutions
over time? What are the points of resemblance between the post war
constitutions of
You will need to give me a preliminary paper topic on March 1, and a draft (which I will not grade but will comment on) is due to me no later than April 12. You must do a draft and turn in a preliminary paper topic, failure to do so will mean that I dock your paper grade by 5%.
Weekly readings:
Jan 11: Miguel Schor, “Constitutionalism through the Looking Glass of
Latin America,” vol 41 Texas International Law Journal 1 (2006); “General
Introduction” and Table of Contents, Anastopolo,
Jan. 18: main reading: Fitzsimmons, Remaking
of
Documents: Patrick Henry speech (Anastopolo); Declaration of the Rights of Man
(France, 1789, Anastopolo);
Jan 25:
Feb. 1: main reading: Gargarella, Roberto. “Towards a Typology of Latin American
Constitutionalism, 1810-1860. Latin
American Research Review 39 (2004): 141-153 (on line, check UF e-journals);
Doorenspleet, Renske. “Reassessing the Three Waves of Democratization,” World Politics 52 (2000): 384-406
(available on line, check UF e-journals).
Document: Constitution of
Mexico (1824);
Feb. 8: Documents: Constitution of the Confederate
States of America (1861); Constitution
of Mexico (1857) (in Spanish); Mill On
Feb. 15: main reading: Kuhn, Origins
of the Modern Chinese State
Documents: Constitution of the Empire
of Japan (1889); Stephen,
Feb. 22: Documents: Constitution of
Mexico, 1917; Weimar
Constitution (Germany) (1919) (in English)
March 1: main reading: Moore and Robinson, Partners for Democracy
Documents: Constitution of Japan
(1947); German Basic Laws
(1949)
March 8: main reading: Jacobsohn, Apple
of Gold
Documents: Israel’s
Basic Laws
***
book report due***
March 15: Spring break
March 22: main reading: Brzenzski, Struggle
for Constitutionalism in Poland
Document: Constitution of
Poland (1997)
March 29: main reading: Klug, Constituting
Democracy
Document: Constitution of
the Republic of South Africa (1997)
April 5: main reading: Brown, Constitutions
in a Nonconstitutional World
Document: Saudi Arabia Basic Laws
(1993)
April 12: Berg and Geyer, Two
Cultures of Rights
April 19: no session, paper conferences
April 26: papers due